Syed Irfan Shah vs Shia Zakir on Tv:

Masha ALLAH very good answer by Syed Irfan Shah,Felt like slapping the shia zakir!

Allah ny Quran mai Farmaya hy "un ky dilon per mohrain lagi hui hain", shia alam is talking about the respect of Azwaaj-e-Nabi(SAAW), aur wo keh rha hy ky is yeh jo likha hua hy bukhari sharef mai yeh theek nhi hy...magr sunni alam isay dusri side ly gia hy....check the attached file taken from bukhari shareef, what is written in it.

We know the respect of azwaaj-e-Nabi(SAAW), thats why our shia alam are condemning these fake ahadees.

Think before speak.

Mohsin

Shahmohsin,


How come Shia alim are good at attacking Sunni books, but never look into there own books which are crammed with lies and kuffar?

Which Shia schlor have you seen giving lecture to the awaam about there books and the kufr it holds?

Why attack Bhukhari, Muslim etc our Sunni books have proper Sanad, and our hadeeths are clearly told by our schlor if they are zaeef, Sahih, Hassan etc.. where your hadeeth books are still being analysed to find sahih and zaeef...

Dont you think the shia alims need to sort there own books out first, rather attacks Sunni books...

by the way before you give us any Wahabi lecture, we do not believe Sunni hadeet books are ALL SAHIH, they do contain ZAEEF hadeeth to.

Wasalam

I don't know about which shia books you are talking?. If you have any reference to any book, plz let me know that. And I am not giving you any wahabi lecture. I have just pointed one fake hadees in Bukhari Sharef book, for which i have provided the book page as well.

Thanks,

mohsin

Mohsinshah,

if you were really screwed on about your shia religion, then you would know straight way which books I am referring to... go and ask your schlors about your book Usole Kaafi, Bihar un Anwar, Rijal Kashi the amount of fabricated and kufr these book contain in unbelivable.

like i clearly said Sahih Bhukhari can also have zaeef hadeeths....

Thanks

See our books contain the material which is according to Quran. Even our Beloved Imams(AS) said that if you find a ahadees which is negating Quran, consider it as fake. So we strongly believe in Quran.

I have Bihar ul Anwar and Usoof-e-Kaafi, plz tell me what you find wrong in these books?


Thanks

shahmohsin46 wrote:
See our books contain the material which is according to Quran. Even our Beloved Imams(AS) said that if you find a ahadees which is negating Quran, consider it as fake. So we strongly believe in Quran.

I have Bihar ul Anwar and Usoof-e-Kaafi, plz tell me what you find wrong in these books?


Thanks

hahaha your books contain material according to Quran???

well that above statement of your just shows me you are not worth wasting time...

Ok just for you today later when i get home I will post some of the kuffar that is in the shia books... just saying that it goes agaisnt the Quran is not enough...

oh so you believe in the Qruan...

ok do me one small favour.. go to any ayatollah of yours and get me one fatwa from them that states that anyone who beliefs in TEHREEF of Quran is kaffir... just one...

we sunnis have clear fatwa that anyone who does tehreef of Quran is KAFFIR!!! that is because we blieve in the Quran to be complate and not one word wrong...

lets see how much you believe in the Quran, now get me one fatwa form your authorative schlor regardign Quran Tehreef....

lets talk about Qurna before we jump anywhere!

if you want open another topic just about Quran and only me and you will discuss on that topic?

Do you know what happened after the Wisaal of Prophet(PBUH)?. None other than Imam Ali(AS) was close to Prophet(PBUH), and Imam Ali(AS) collected the Quran and gave it a shape of book and brought it to 1st caliph but the caliph rejected that Quran. Why he did so? do you?
So if we shia say about tehreef of Quran, we talk with refernece to that.

Yes open the topic about Quran and i will join you there.

Note: I have limited knowledge and i can answer you accordingly.

Thanks

Mohsin